Whether you’re craving the comfort food of a family-owned, family-friendly restaurant, an enchanting meal with a waterfront view, or a friendly place to get your morning scone and cup of coffee, there’s no shortage of choices for dining in Sister Bay.
Many a visitor has referred to Sister Bay as “the” place to go for dining, and with this many varied choices, it’s easy to see why. If it’s a fine dining experience that you’re after, many of the village’s award-winning fine dining restaurants have been featured in magazines such as Good Housekeeping, Midwest Living, Gourmet, and Bon Appetit, as well as on The Food Network channel. With a list of over 500 carefully selected wines, scotches, and signature martinis, One Sister Bay dining establishment is a nine-time Wine Spectator Award winner and is one of only five restaurants in Wisconsin to receive the “Best Award of Excellence Award” from Wine Spectator Magazine. Another Sister Bay restaurant was recently named one of the state’s best restaurants in a reader’s poll by Wisconsin newspapers, as well as previously being named the most romantic restaurant by the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel. With waterfront views, outdoor seating, and private dining rooms for large groups or parties, Sister Bay’s gourmet establishments have every detail of your dining experience covered!
Sister Bay is very proud of its Scandinavian heritage – and that pride translates into many of the dishes served in our restaurants. We have three full-service restaurants that serve authentic Scandinavian dishes (with the portions to match!). And of course, talking about Sister Bay eateries would not be complete without mentioning “the icons” – our many restaurants that have been family-owned and operated for many years. With plenty of hard work (not to mention great food!), there a few dining establishments that have been part of the Sister Bay lifestyle for 50 years – or more! These restaurants have grown to become part of Sister Bay’s modern heritage – and by number of families that keep returning to Sister Bay year after year, it looks like these places will be part of our village for another fifty years.
However, dining in Sister Bay is much more than an expertly grilled steak, a tasty Friday night fish-fry, or that perfect bottle of wine to accompany your meal. In our village that encompasses three square miles, we have homemade ice-cream, the perfect latte or mocha to begin your morning, tasty burgers, homemade soups, whitefish and other varieties of fish caught by our own local fishermen daily, homemade pizzas, and of course, Door County cherry pie – all with accommodations for every group, budget, and palate. With this many dining choices, Sister Bay provides a bit of a pleasant dilemma. After all, how can you fit a two week’s worth of dining choices into a few days? Might just have to come back and visit us again!
Indicates "Open in Winter"
Al Johnson’s Swedish Restaurant& Butik, 10698 N. Bay Shore Drive, in the center of Sister Bay. Open 6 a.m. to 9 p.m. May to Oct.; 7 a.m. to 8 p.m. Nov. to April. Swedish atmosphere and food specialties. 920-854-2626; Web: www.aljohnsons.com.
CheeseCake, Etc., 10579 Country Walk Dr., Sister Bay. Bakery, Eatery, Funnery, Meals and More featuring Homemade, All Fresh, All Natural, All Dangerous CheeseCakes by the slice or by the cake, made in our Sister Bay kitchen. Kosher Premium Ice Cream and Gourmet Kosher Coffee. 99¢ Waffles; Soups, Salads, Sandwiches. We cater meals and customize CheeseCakes for special occasions. Come in for a FREE taste of ice cream! FREE WIFI. 920-854-5000;
This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it
. *
Door County Bakery, 10048 Hwy. 57, Sister Bay. Home of the famous CORSICA LOAF, and famous for their foundation of pastries, cakes, pies and Stone Oven Breads. Embellished with a beautiful atmosphere and full delicatessen, including many choice meats and seafoods. European coffee bar and several hundred wines, beers and spirits. Indoor-outdoor seating for breakfasts and luncheons, and a new wine-beer-spirits bar. Call for seasonal hours. 920-854-1137 or 888-392-7323; E-mail:
This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it
; Web: www.doorcountybakery.com.
Door County Ice Cream Factory & Sandwich Shoppe, 11051 Hwy 42, Sister Bay. Now entering our 18th season! Homemade ice cream, sundaes, homemade waffle cones, delicious pizza, sandwiches, soups, and salads are all served up in a historic building circa 1912, lined with old photos of Sister Bay and the surrounding area. May-Oct. 920-854-9693Web:www.doorcountyicecream.com
Fred & Fuzzy's, 10620 Little Sister Rd., Sister Bay (Adj. to Bay Ridge Golf Course) Door County's best kept secret. A place to dine on our scenic shoreline. Sit outside or under our awning-enclosed and heated in spring & fall. Grilled sandwiches, full bar, awesome sunsets & storm watching. Open daily. Perch Wednesdays and Fridays. 920-854-6699.
Husby's Food & Spirits, 10641 N. Bayshore Drive, Sister Bay. Great burgers, soups, salads, and sandwiches for lunch. Evening selections include dinner entrees, Mexican specialties and pizza. Friday perch fry, Saturday prime rib. For entertainment and Fall Fest schedules go towww.husbys.com. 920-854-2624.
Inn at Kristofer’s, 10716 N. Bay Shore Dr., Sister Bay. Situated at the north end of Sister Bay, adjacent to the scenic Sister Bay marina, Kristofer’s offers large floor-to-ceiling windows. Patrons can take full advantage of spectacular Door County sunsets over the water of Green Bay and the bluffs of Sister Bay as they enjoy exceptional fine dining cuisine. 920-854-9419; www.innatkristofers.com.
Mission Grille, Intersection Hwys 42 & 57. Sister Bay. Casual and delightful fine dining in a beautifully remodeled old church building. Innovative new American cuisine plus Chef’s daily specialties, vegetarian, gluten-free. Wine Spectator Award (11 years). Wine, Martini & Tapas Bar. May-October: Lunch & Dinner daily & Sunday brunch; Nov.-April: Dinner Friday-Sunday. Outdoor dining. Catering. Reservations accepted. 920-854-9070; Web:www.missiongrille.com.
Moretti's Italian Eatery & Pizzeria, 10649 N. Bay Shore Drive, downtown Sister Bay. Door County's oldest and best pizzeria. Hand-tossed pizzas are made from scratch, loaded with your choice of fresh ingredients and baked to perfection. Our full menu features homemade appetizers, authentic pastas, fresh salads and sandwiches to fill any size appetite. Outdoor seating. Beer and wine. Dine in-Carry Out-Delivery. Pet-friendly dining on patio. 920-854-6610. Web:www.morettispizzeria.com
Patio Restaurant, S. Sister Bay, Hwy 57. Featuring tasty burgers, homemade soups, delicious malts, shakes and dairy treats. Dine in, take out or eat on patio. Late May through Oct. Closed Sundays. 920-854-1978; Web: www.patiomotelandrestaurant.com.
Rowleys Bay Restaurant & Grandma’s Swedish Bakery, 1041 County Road ZZ, Rowleys Bay.We offer the only all-you-can-eat fish boil in Door County every Saturday night. In addition to a full menu and bar, we also feature the area’s longest buffet and salad bar—a tremendous dining value. Our from scratch bakery items--decadent pecan rolls, pastries, cinnamon rolls—tantalize the taste buds. Free WI-FI in bakery. 920-854-2385 or 800-999-2466; Web: www.rowleysbayresort.com.
Sarah's Snack Shop, Cedar Shops across from Beach Park. Sandwiches, pizza, bakery, milkshakes, smoothies, coffee, soda, etc. A snack "just like you would have at home". Specializing in cherry pie. A great selection of Door County T-shirts and sweatshirts. Open 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. daily in season. 920-854-5977.
Sub Express @ Sister Bay Mobil, 2579 S. Bay Shore Dr. It’s a restaurant with gas pumps! At the Sister Bay Mobil, Hwy. 42 in front of Pamida. Daily lunch specials, fresh subs & pizza, homemade soups, Door County chili, Breakfast sandwiches, espresso & more. Take out or eat in! Drive-thru. WIFI. 920-854-6700.
Viking Grill & Lounge, 12029 Hwy 42, Ellison Bay. Smoke free dining room. Casual, affordable dining in a friendly atmosphere. Made from scratch menu includes hearty breakfasts, specialty lunches, exciting dinner entrees, famous Whitefish chowder. Home of the outdoor fish boil. Open 6 a.m. 920-854-2998• Web: www.thevikinggrill.com
